You’re about to hit the big open sea, and you’re not certain what type of boat to go with.
Sailboats are generally perceived as a more relaxing and rewarding boating experience, and powerboats are put in beer commercials and high-octane movies that make them seem incredibly fun.
You’ve got a tough choice to make, but we’re going to do our best to help you make that decision as concisely as possible with the pros, cons, and cost differences between sailboats and powerboats.
First thing’s first: it’s a different lifestyle choice.
When you go out on a sailboat for the day, you’re not planning on being back in two hours to have brunch, or bound to a tight schedule.
You know how fast the boat goes and how much time it’s going to take, and that’s okay by you, because you want to take it easy.
With a powerboat, you’re moving a lot faster. Powerboats can maintain a balanced speed of about 47 MPH, and excel up to 80 MPH on mid-tier models (though expensive boats can go much faster).
That’s a crazy speed difference between the max of a sailboat, being somewhere in the 10 MPH to 30 MPH range, and that depends on if you’re riding a catamaran competitive racing sailboat or a traditional monohull.
So there’s a big gap in what sailboats can do, and what powerboats can do.
One is designed for leisure, the other is designed for more high-octane fun, but those aren’t the only differences between them.
There’s safety, cost, and a few other big factors to consider before you make the plunge on which type of boat to buy.
Some Quick Pros and Cons of Sailboats and Powerboats
If you’re short on time and can’t delve deeper into this post, that’s okay.
Let’s discuss a quick list of the main benefits and drawbacks of each boat type to help you make a more informed decision before you go through the purchase process.
Different pros and cons are going to jump out at you with varying priority levels, which will help you make a better decision.
- Better for the Environment: No fuel burning, no major disturbance of underwater life, nothing but the free wind that pulls your boat along. A sailboat is a more environmentally conscious option.
- Inexpensive Engine Maintenance: You could replace the entire sailboat assistance motor for a lot less than a powerboat motor, and repairs are cheap as well. On top of that, they are less complex engines, so you can perform maintenance on your own.
- Cheap Long Distance Travel: The wind is your only fuel source, minus a few gallons here and there in your assistance motor if the conditions aren’t perfect. Want to travel the world or bridge a gap between here and another country? Sailboats are the way to go.
- Quiet Operation: There’s no motor sounds rippling through your ears. Even if you use the assistance of your V2 motor during lulls in the wind, it’s fairly quiet and won’t prevent you from having conversations at a normal volume.
- Easier to Maneuver: While powerboats might be better at getting out of tight spots, the buoyancy and hull design of a sailboat allows for more dynamic movements and a better range of motion. Powerboats glide on the water; sailboats traverse it.
- Not Much Space: There’s less room for you, and more room for your equipment. Walking around a sailboat can be slightly perilous, especially for passengers who are trying to find somewhere to relax.
- Waiting for the Conditions: If you’re relying solely on sail power, then you’re going to be sitting still for a while throughout the day. Sailing requires more patience than powerboating in most scenarios.
- Long Castoff Times: Depending on how big your sailboat is, it can take an hour to a few hours to get everything in order before you cast off.
- Faster Travel: You can literally travel 10x the speed of a standard sailboats, and 3.5-4x the speed of the fastest racing sailboats in history.
- More Deck Space: Sailboats have a lot going on, and a lot of spots you can’t step. There’s room for everyone on a powerboat, just about anywhere that there’s space.
- Minimal Training Required: Can you operate a motor? Can you steer with slight competence? That’s all a powerboat requires.
- More Open Travel Options: Without the mast, you can clear lower bridges, explore more places, and get around a lot easier in tighter areas than with a sailboat.
- Generally Easier to Use: In terms of casting off, operation, maintenance and time spent, powerboats are a faster and slightly easier option.
- Expensive Operation: Diesel fuel is expensive, and nothing is going to eat it up like a powerboat motor. Expect to pay a lot for all-day outings and any travel in general.
- Very Loud: Powerboat motors mean nobody can hear each other speak, and you won’t be able to hear yourself think. Prepare for the thunderous volume:
- Unreliable in Harsh Conditions: Due to the lightweight construction, strong winds are going to throw you off course and make navigation challenging. Greater chance of capsizing.
The Bottom Line
What it all comes down to is preference: what do you picture yourself doing while you’re out on the boat?
Is it about a sporty and fun day while tanning on deck, or enjoying the power and glory of nature while navigating through it?
Boat parties or technical skill and know-how to get you through the day? It’s your journey, just be sure to have the right vessel.
Are Sailboats Safer than Powerboats?
Either way you look at it, boating is safer than driving a car.
Statistically speaking, you’re twice as safe on a boat than you are in a traffic jam during rush hour in your four-door sedan.
There’s this apparent rivalry in the community between sailboaters and powerboaters, but to keep things as fair and open as possible, we’re going to objectively look at both and determine their safety.
Speed and Momentum
The faster you go, the more likely you are to crash.
That’s just a fact.
Powerboats are able to travel faster than sailboats not just because of the engine, but because of the way they are designed.
In our article on the anatomy of a sailboat, we discuss the important of the shape of the stem and the keel.
Well, powerboats don’t usually have a keel, which means there’s less drag on the bottom. In a sailboat, the keel is there for weight balance and distribution.
There are a number of different designs that attempt to cut down on drag as much as possible, but that’s just not an issue you need to worry about on a powerboat.
Minus that from the design, and reshape the hull to be a deeper vee than most sailboats, and you’ve built something that’s designed to plane on top of the water.
Since buoyancy is based on the water displaced by the weight of the object, powerboats are built to be lightweight and remain afloat, but not handle large cargo or big parties of people.
Of course, this depends on the size of your powerboat.
Durability and Construction
Being built of lighter materials, powerboats are going to sustain a lot more damage during a collision than a sailboat will.
While there are more parts to a sailboat (mast, keel, etc.), the damage to a powerboat will also be more expensive as a result.
Since the motor is in the back, you’re not likely to damage that too badly, but with a narrower hull and stem design, there’s less resistance against pressure and force.
When it comes to the motor, powerboat motors are more durable than a small V2 sailboat motor, and as a result have a lot more maintenance that comes with owning one.
The interior of a V6 engine (most common small to mid-sized powerboat motor) is as complex as your car motor, and it’s recommended that maintenance and tune-ups be done by a professional.
Are Sailboats Cheaper than Powerboats?
By a lot.
Sailboats rely on wind power and minor motor power (which is optional, and most smaller sailboats around 16 ft don’t usually come with motors anyway).
Which means that you’re paying for a mast, sails, and a few other sailboat components that you don’t have to worry about with a powerboat.
If you do an independent search right now, you’ll find that a 19 ft sailboat is going to run you approximately $19,000 to $25,000, depending on what brand you go with.
Compare that to a powerboat of the same length from a cost-effective brand like Yamaha, and you’re looking at $32,000.
Enough searching will yield the same inevitable truth time after time: powerboats are more expensive than sailboats, and they should be.
The thing about powerboats is that you can cover more than 10x the maximum daily travel distance of a sailboat, and in less time.
If you want to go out to sea and skip across the waves to a far-off destination, you can cover hundreds of miles a day. It’s going to cost you a ton in fuel consumption, but it’s still doable.
We talked about maintenance with both types of boats. It’s true that powerboats are more expensive, but there’s a lot less that you have to worry about.
With a sailboat, depending on what style you side with, there are a lot more working parts that need tending to on a daily basis.
That means more frequent maintenance, even if they are small and fairly simple tasks. It takes a lot more time to get a sailboat ready for departure than it does a powerboat.
You’re paying more for a sleeker boat that runs far faster than a sailboat can.
The aesthetic and functional differences between sailboats and powerboats attract different crowds.
The good news (there had to be some, right?) is that marina costs only differ based on the size of the boat.
No marina is going to care about what power source your boat is using, so long as it’s not polluting the water or preventing other boaters from docking there.
You can expect prices based on occupancy duration, length of the boat, in some cases the weight (if the marina in question offers indoor storage/yard storage during the winter months), and that’s really all. The bigger the space that you take up, the more you’ll pay.
Prices are going to majorly differ here.
You’ll find some opinions that say, “Either way, an engine repair is an engine repair, so it doesn’t matter what type of engine you have.” That’s a fallacy.
A V2 engine is what your sailboat likely uses, unless you’re getting into fairly large 55 ft+ sailboats.
A V2 offers motor assistance when you need it, and doesn’t eat up a lot of fuel or send you speeding and skipping across the waves.
V2 engines are used in ATVs and small vehicles, and can cost around $800 to replace, and even less to repair.
Powerboats use either V6 or V8 engines, which brand new can cost about $2,000 to $2,400 to replace. Depending on the issue(s), it will be cheaper to repair it rather than to replace it.
But you’re looking at a potential 66% increase in price from a sailboat engine. These prices also don’t reflect the propeller as a heads up.
Apart from the engine, this includes cleaning below deck, cleaning/waxing the exterior, checking for and protecting against corrosion, water intake valves, shaft seals, and a lot more.
You should be inspecting your boat twice a year to make sure that you catch anything that could potentially be wrong with it.
This one actually goes to powerboats, because they have a lot fewer things that could go wrong.
Sailboats not only have a lot of things above deck, but damages or dings to your stem and keel aren’t exactly uncommon, and can greatly impact your performance.
You don’t have a powerful motor to carry you through the water; everything counts.
We consider equipment to be what you bring on board to help with your voyage, as well as personal wear that is specifically designed to impact your time out at sea in one way or another.
You’ll run into a lot of the same costs, such as waterproof backpacks, dry bags, boat shoes, headlamps (nighttime use), and AIS device, GPS, flotation devices, and more.
You won’t find a great fluctuation in these departments, because the market ambiguously targets anyone who owns a boat, not necessarily sailboat or powerboat owners.
Fuel Cost Difference
Either way, you’re using a diesel engine, and fuel isn’t going to be cheap.
Boat motors tend to use similar efficiencies across multiple brands so you’re not getting a major benefit with one brand over another.
The larger your boat, the more fuel you’re going to consume to move it, just like with a compact car versus an SUV.
You’ll use a lot of fuel for a V6 engine: the more horsepower an engine creates, the more fuel it’s going to use. The are six cylinders, each using more gas.
Of course the tradeoff is that you’ll be exceling much faster than a weaker engine, but you will definitely have to pay for it.
Since there’s no free alternative of wind energy to carry you across the waves, you absolutely have to have reserve fuel on deck to keep things moving.
That means buying fuel containers and having a designated storage space for them.
Ideally, your sailboat will use less than a couple of gallons of diesel for assistance during an all-day voyage. That will cost you about $10.00 on average.
Powerboats burn through diesel like you wouldn’t believe, and an all-day trip could cost you about $200+ if you keep close to the shore and park it periodically to enjoy the sunshine.
Sailing vs. Cruising
Sailing is putting the full power of the wind to work for you by filling up the mainsail, and letting it rip.
Powerboats do have settings for speeds, but “cruising” isn’t a term that we’d use to describe them.
There’s not one definition of cruising; it’s essentially travelling at low speeds or calmly moving through the water, with the expectation of relaxing or leisure.
The important thing is that you’re out there on the water on a boat of your choosing, and you’re enjoying your time.
Which Is Right for You?
You’ve learned the primary differences between sailboats and powerboats, but since we don’t know enough about you, it’s up to you to decide which one is going to best suit your lifestyle and expectations of the big murky blue.
Sailboats are better for leisure and involved adjustments while you learn the water, powerboats are better suited for high-octane fun and quick ventures out into the water. What will you choose?
Last updated on: